This isn't football, folks...
It's more like soccer. Via Meryl's, Laurence shares with us this AP story:
GAZA CITY, Gaza Strip - Militant groups in the Gaza Strip have agreed to stop firing missiles at Israel at midnight Saturday, senior Palestinian officials said.The unilateral cease-fire is aimed at ending an Israeli offensive in the Gaza Strip that began June 28, three days after militants raided an Israeli army post, killing two soldiers and capturing a third, 19-year-old Cpl. Gilad Shalit, the officials said on condition of anonymity because the agreement was reached at a closed meeting.
There are no timeouts. And you're out of substitutions. You started this, and now you'd like to all sit down on the field and try to get Israel to stop playing?
And since Meryl is down for the count, I'll ask: Is AP really the credentialed ambassador to the world for Hamas? If so, good to know.
Update: I just noticed this at the bottom of the AP story:
In fighting in Gaza on Friday, four people were killed — a Hamas activist and three relatives — in an explosion at his home in Gaza City, hospital officials said. Palestinians said the house was hit by an Israeli tank shell. The Israeli military denied using artillery or tanks.
Contrast that with what I noted here, where Ha'aretz reports that the IDF confirmed it was a tank shell, or at Israel Today:
An initial Israeli inquiry into the incident revealed that soldiers spotted two Palestinians attempting to fire an anti-tank missile at the forces out of a house's balcony. A tank fired a shell and the two suspects were hit.
The only thing I can posit is that since everyone knows that the IDF fired on the house (even the IDF, darn them for admitting it!), the AP will tell us that the IDF denies it, thus casting doubt on all IDF statements in the future. Or, maybe, they're just incompetent.





Comments
The Israeli military did deny using tanks... in Lebanon. My bet is either that AP's got some people confused about the fronts in this war, and applying a quote from the North to the South, or else that some IDF spokesman really did say, "of course we aren't using tanks on Gaza." Certainly, our own miltary's spokesmen are often a few hours or days behind the operational edge.
Posted by: Brian Sniffen
|
July 22, 2006 03:25 PM
(I wonder how this will look in terms of my typekey identity - crs here)
You do seem to lay all the burden for any chance of miscommunication on the AP in that last bit of this story. There are nigh infinite explanations for the discrepencies between the two stories, but you choose only to list ones that smack of conspiracy theories of anti-Semitism in the mass media.
Posted by: lochinola
|
July 23, 2006 11:48 PM
Oops, let me soften my last sentence there. You only choose the ones that cast the AP in a bad light. The "incompetency" one is clearly not a conspiracy theory :)
Posted by: lochinola
|
July 23, 2006 11:50 PM
Because the press is biased.
You are right; incompetent journalism, making it up journalism, and lazy journalism probably could account for the error here. None of those seem to be causes to celebrate the AP, though.
Posted by: Andy
|
July 23, 2006 11:58 PM